Having a father with diabetes means I am regularly making dessert for him without sugar. He has a few favorites up his sleeve, but when he requests a diabetic-friendly cookie, I make him my famous sugar free cookies!
Now, not all sugar substitutes are equal, so I did extensive recipe testing using every popular kind on the market. In culinary school, we learned that sugar isn’t just about sweetness- it impacts texture, browning, and even how soft a cookie stays. After all that testing, the clear winner as allulose, which mimics real sugar almost perfectly, and is the sweetener I use here.
The result? Cookies that taste like they came straight from a bakery: crisp edges, soft middles, and nearly impossible to stop at just one.
Why I love this recipe
3 Ingredients. No flour and no grains are needed, just pantry staples!
Quick and easy. With less than two minutes of prep and ten minutes of cooking time, these could not be any easier.
Low in carbs. Not only are these completely sugar-free, but they are also keto-friendly.
No bitter aftertaste. Sugar substitutes are known for leaving desserts with a slightly bitter taste, but not these ones!
Key Ingredients
Find the printable recipe with measurements below.
- Almond butter or peanut butter. Smooth and creamy with no added sugar (just look for one with a touch of salt).
- Sugar substitute. I like to use allulose, but you can try a brown sugar substitute or powdered sugar substitute. In testing, I found monk fruit to be too gritty (although pleasantly sweet) and stevia to be a bit bitter and artificial tasting.
- Egg. Always use room-temperature eggs. It prevents the cookies from crumbling once cooled.
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
